Beyond Discounts: Controversial Ways to Keep Customers Coming Back

Are you relying on the same old tactics to keep your customers coming back?

Many brands are, but here’s the thing – sticking to conventional strategies might just leave you in the dust.

Today, we’re diving into some controversial techniques for customer retention that are shaking up the industry. By the end of this issue, you’ll have fresh ideas to keep your customers engaged and loyal, even in the face of fierce competition.

Let’s get into it.

The Downside of Playing It Safe

Most e-commerce businesses stick to the tried-and-true methods: discounts, loyalty programs, and excellent customer service. While these strategies are important, they’re not always enough to stand out in a crowded market.

Playing it safe can lead to stagnation. When everyone is doing the same thing, your brand blends into the background.

It’s time to explore some unconventional approaches that might make you uncomfortable but could yield significant rewards.

Overlooked Techniques That Deserve Attention

Have you ever considered these bold tactics?

1. Personalization Beyond First Names

Using a customer’s first name in emails is standard practice. But what if you could personalize your interactions even further?

Behavioral Email Triggers: Analyze customer behavior on your site and send tailored emails based on their actions. For instance, if a customer frequently views high-end products but doesn’t purchase, offer them a personalized discount or a VIP experience.

This can be done through a combination of analytic tools, segmentation, targeted campaigns, and atomated email tools.

Custom Product Recommendations: Use AI to suggest products based on browsing history and previous purchases (tools like Nosto and Dynamic Yield can help with this). Make the experience feel bespoke.

2. Creating a Sense of Exclusivity

People love to feel special. Creating a sense of exclusivity can drive customer loyalty and repeat purchases.

Invite-Only Sales: Host sales events that are accessible only to your most loyal customers. This makes them feel valued and encourages repeat business.

Membership Tiers: Introduce membership levels that offer escalating perks. The higher the tier, the more exclusive the benefits, encouraging customers to spend more to access better rewards.

3. Leveraging Scarcity Effectively

Scarcity can be a powerful motivator, but it has to be genuine. False scarcity can damage trust.

Limited Edition Products: Release products in limited quantities to create urgency. Customers will be more likely to purchase if they know the item won’t be available forever.

Countdown Timers: Use countdown timers for special promotions to instill a sense of urgency. Make sure these are based on real availability to maintain trust.

Why These Techniques Work

These strategies work because they tap into fundamental human psychology: the desire for exclusivity, urgency, and personalized attention. By leveraging these principles, you can create a more engaging and compelling shopping experience.

Implementing Controversial Techniques

Adopting these tactics requires a careful approach. Here’s how to get started:

1. Understand Your Audience

Before you can implement any of these techniques, you need to have a deep understanding of your audience. What motivates them? What are their pain points?

Action Step: Conduct surveys, analyze purchase data, and engage with customers directly to gather insights.

2. Start Small

Test these strategies on a small scale before rolling them out widely. This allows you to measure effectiveness and make adjustments without risking your entire customer base.

Action Step: Pick one technique to pilot over a limited period or with a small segment of your audience.

3. Monitor and Adapt

Continually monitor the results of these techniques and be prepared to adapt. What works for one audience may not work for another.

Action Step: Use analytics tools to track customer behavior and adjust your strategies based on the data.

Today’s Action Steps

Here’s how you can act on this advice today:

  1. Identify Behavioral Triggers: List key actions customers take on your site that could be used for personalized email triggers.
  2. Create Exclusive Offers: Plan an invite-only sale or develop a membership tier system that offers escalating perks.
  3. Plan a Limited Edition Release: Identify a product that could be offered in limited quantities and plan the logistics around its release.
  4. Implement a Countdown Timer: Choose a promotion and add a countdown timer to your site to create urgency.

By embracing these controversial techniques, you can break away from the pack and keep your customers coming back for more. It’s time to innovate and transform your customer retention strategy.

See you next week,
Josh

Whenever You're Ready, Here's 2 Ways I Can Help You:

1. Subscribe to Behind The Screens: My weekly newsletter where each Saturday, I dig into a particular topic in online retail with a combination of insights, strategies and/or action guides to help you online retail grow. Sign up for free here.

2. Follow me on Social Media: I publish various tips and ideas for growing your business in a more socially-digestible manner. You can find me on LinkedIn and X.

Share this article on:

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Join the list of subscribers that get one tip to launch, grow, and scale their online retail business every week.